Lough Swilly Oyster Dredging Consultation Response Nov 2026 

This consultation has gone a long way to assessing the likely environmental impacts of oyster dredging.

Inland Fisheries Ireland (IFI) has a responsibility to maximise sustainability and natural biodiversity.

Environmental impacts must therefore be considered holistically when granting licences for shellfish aquaculture and any associated dredging operations.

The rivers Leannan ( SAC 002176), Crana and Mill river( Owenkillew) are recognised salmon and sea trout rivers. Lough Swilly and the other bays listed for shellfish dredging provide a feeding ground for salmonid sea trout.

Lough Swilly provides a vital corridor for out migrating salmon smolts from the Leannan, Crana river.

It is well recognised within IFI that Atlantic salmon and seatrout are a vital resource in Ireland offering fishing opportunities that benefit angling and community interests. It is vital that the supporting ecological services are fully considered to ensure the protection and quality of the ecological habitats supporting salmonids and native oysters. Is there a need to farm native oysters and the consequent dredging?  

The consultation recognises only noise impacts on salmonid fish. However dredging operations will produce damaging sediment. Therefore, reassurances that no negative consequences for sea trout ecology and salmon smolt migration would be apparent is required.

Impacts on sea trout could result from physical habitat disturbance, sediment smothering of habitat which provides the base benthic ecological communities necessary a food habitat resource.

Trophic level food chain impacts need to be considered as these could impact sea trout feeding and other prey species. Eg sand eels.

The business opportunities offered by shellfish farming must be weighed against its environmental impacts, particularly on salmonids.

This is an opportunity-cost consideration: the desirable benefits forgone when one alternative is chosen over another. Any shellfish aquaculture and associated dredging must therefore be balanced against their effects on sea trout feeding zones and the benthic ecosystems that support them.

The consultation presents an opportunity to consider the holistic benefits to be gained by declining or granting dredging licenses for aquaculture (native oysters) and opportunities for environmentally beneficial operations. Any positive environmental impacts provided by low impact shellfish farming need to be economically balanced against negative consequences that impact the value of external opportunities.

It is hope that IFI will consider this in its decision to grant or not grant licenses for aquaculture

Brendan Kerr

Natural Living Assets

12 Nov 20266